+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Choice of vascular surgery as a specialty: survey of vascular surgery residents, general surgery chief residents, and medical students at hospitals with vascular surgery training programs



Choice of vascular surgery as a specialty: survey of vascular surgery residents, general surgery chief residents, and medical students at hospitals with vascular surgery training programs



Journal of Vascular Surgery 40(5): 978-984



Purpose: Under the direction of the Association of Program Directors in Vascular Surgery, a survey was mailed to vascular surgery residents (VSRs), general surgery chief residents (GS-CRs), and fourth-year medical students (MSs) to better define reasons why trainees do and do not choose vascular surgery as a career. Methods: Questionnaires were mailed to all accredited VSR programs and their associated GS programs in the United States and Canada in 2001 (survey 1) and in 2003 (survey 2) and to 2 medical schools with VSR programs in 2001. A total of 197 VSRs, 169 GS-CRs, and 78 MSs responded (overall program response rate of 78% for VSRs, 46% for GSRs, 20% for MSs). A scoring system was assigned, with 1.0 the least important and 5.0 the most important reasons to choose or not choose vascular surgery. Results. Technical aspects, role of mentors, and complex decision making involved in vascular surgery were the most important reasons that VSRs, GS-CRs, and MSs would choose vascular surgery as a specialty (average scores gtoreq4.0 for VSRs and GS-CRs; gtoreq3.5 for MSs). Responses of GS-CRs and VSRs did not vary significantly between surveys I and 2, except endovascular capabilities of vascular surgeons had a more important role in choosing vascular surgery, and future loss of patients to other interventionalists had a more important role in not choosing this specialty in the more recent survey of GS-CRs and VSRs. MSs identified lifestyle as a surgical resident (4.3) and as a surgeon (4.2) as the most important negative factors. A training paradigm consisting of 4 years general surgery + 2 years vascular surgery with a GS certificate was favored by 64% of GS-CRs and 48% of VSRs, compared with a paradigm of 5 years + 2 years with a general surgery certificate, which was favored by 29% of GS-CRs and 25% of VSRs, or 3 years + 3 years without a general surgery certificate, favored by 7% of GS-CRs and 27% of VSRs. Of note, 86% of MSs favored 3 years general surgery + 3 years vascular surgery or 2 years general surgery + 4 years vascular surgery compared with longer general surgery training periods. Conclusion: These findings may help vascular surgery program directors devise strategies to attract future trainees. The importance of mentorship to general surgery junior residents and medical students in choosing vascular surgery cannot be overestimated. Endovascular capabilities of vascular surgeons have an increasingly positive role in career choice by GS-CRs and VSRs, but these residents express increasing concerns about potential loss of patients to other specialists. Lifestyle concerns are the most important reasons why medical students do not choose vascular surgery as a career.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 011856705

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 15557914

DOI: 10.1016/j.jvs.2004.08.036


Related references

Vascular surgical training of general and vascular surgery residents. Journal of Vascular Surgery 24(6): 1057-1063, 1996

0 + 5 Vascular Surgery Residents' Operative Experience in General Surgery: An Analysis of Operative Logs from 12 Integrated Programs. Journal of Surgical Education 73(3): 536-541, 2017

PC118. Impact of Comprehensive Simulation on Military General Surgery Residents Confidence, Knowledge, and Interest in Vascular Surgery. Journal of Vascular Surgery 63(6): 188s-189s, 2016

Training vascular surgery residents in the noninvasive vascular laboratory. Seminars in Vascular Surgery 7(4): 223-227, 1994

Vascular surgery training in general surgery residency programs: the Canadian experience. Journal of Vascular Surgery 38(5): 1012-1017, 2003

Declining Resident Experience in Open Vascular Operations Threatens the Status of Vascular Surgery as an Essential Content Area of General Surgery Training. Annals of Surgery 268(4): 665-673, 2018

Enhancing Confidence in Graduating General Surgery Residents: Establishing a Chief Surgery Resident Service at an Independent Academic Medical Center. Journal of Surgical Education 75(4): 888-894, 2018

Open abdominal surgical training differences experienced by integrated vascular and general surgery residents. Journal of Vascular Surgery 66(4): 1280-1284, 2017

A strategy to improve quality of outpatient education for residents and medical students on a vascular surgery service. Annals of Vascular Surgery 15(3): 288-293, 2001

Canadian Research Awards for Specialty Residents in Medicine and Surgery, Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada - Canadian Research Award for Specialty Residents in the Division of Surgery Insulin cardioplegia for elective coronary bypass surgery. Canadian Journal of Cardiology 16(Supplement F): 141F, 2000

Training general surgery residents in pediatric surgery: A Canadian survey. Journal of Pediatric Surgery 36(5): 706-710, 2001

Evaluation of training of residents and chief-residents in visceral and digestive surgery in France: results of a national survey. Journal of Visceral Surgery 150(5): 297-305, 2014

A national review of the frequency of minimally invasive surgery among general surgery residents: assessment of ACGME case logs during 2 decades of general surgery resident training. JAMA Surgery 150(2): 169-172, 2015

Minimal-access surgery training in the Netherlands: a survey among residents-in-training for general surgery. Surgical Endoscopy 18(12): 1805-1814, 2005

Iatrogenic vascular injuries reconstructive vein surgery experimental vascular surgery 6th annual meeting of the austrian society for vascular surgery in conjunction with the german and swiss society for angiology klagenfurt austria june 21 24 1973. Iatrogenic Vascular Injuries Reconstructive Vein Surgery Experimental Vascular Surgery 6th Annual Meeting Of The Austrian Society For Vascular Surgery in Conjunction With The German And Swiss Society For Angiology Klagenfurt Austria June 21-24 1973 262, 1975