+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Loss of faith in brain death Catholic controversy over the determination of death by neurological criteria



Loss of faith in brain death Catholic controversy over the determination of death by neurological criteria



Clinical Ethics 7(3): 133-141



The diagnosis of death by neurological criteria (colloquially known as ‘brain death’) is accepted in some form in law and medical practice throughout the world, and has been endorsed in principle by the Catholic Church. However, the rationale for this acceptance has been challenged by the accumulation of evidence of integrated vital activity in bodies diagnosed dead by neurological criteria. This paper sets out 10 different Catholic responses to the current crisis of confidence and assesses them in relation to a Catholic understanding of philosophical anthropology. Having considered each of these responses, none is found to provide good grounds for the moral certainty about death needed for current transplant practice to be ethically acceptable. Unless adequate grounds for the use of neurological criteria can be restored, current transplantation practice will have become what Pope John Paul II called a ‘furtive, but no less serious and real, form of euthanasia’.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 036548536

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

DOI: 10.1258/ce.2012.012m07


Related references

Brain death criteria. The neurological determination of death. Neurosciences 13(4): 350-355, 2008

The subject of death. On the current controversy about brain-oriented determination of death. Diskussionsforum Medizinische Ethik 1991(5): Xxxi-Xxxii, 1991

Pope John XXII Medical-Moral Research and Education Center. May Catholic health facilities permit determination of death by brain criteria?. Hospital Progress 64(2): 68, 70-68, 70, 1983

Advancing toward a modern death: the path from severe brain injury to neurological determination of death. Cmaj 168(8): 993-995, 2003

Time of death determination following dissociated death of the brain. Clinical and electroencepholographic criteria. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift 93(14): 679-684, 1968

The dissociated brain death. Clinical and electroencephalographic criteria for determination of death. Minnesota Medicine 51(11): 1563-1567, 1968

The dissociated brain death clinical and inst electro encephalographic criteria for determination of death human. Minnesota Medicine: 1563-1567, 1968

Brain death, death of the cerebral cortex or personal death? On the current discussion of brain-oriented determination of death. Medizinische Klinik 84(10): 483-487, 1989

Restoring Activity of Pig Brain Cells After Death Does not Invalidate the Determination of Death by Neurologic Criteria or Undermine the Propriety of Organ Donation After Death. Transplantation 103(7): 1295-1297, 2019

Transplantation of kidneys from uncontrolled donation after circulatory determination of death: comparison with brain death donors with or without extended criteria and impact of normothermic regional perfusion. Transplant International 29(4): 432-442, 2016

Determination of death by neurological criteria. Journal of Intensive Care Medicine 18(4): 211-221, 2004

Determination of death by neurological criteria. Missouri Medicine 86(9): 628-631, 1989

Criteria of brain death: 3d generation. Interpretation of criteria established by the Federal Chamber of Physicians in determining brain death. Anasthesie Intensivtherapie Notfallmedizin 22(1): 17-20, 1987

Further discussion: determination of death by neurological criteria. National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly 3(4): 667-669, 2003

Declaring brain death: the neurological criteria. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8(3): 640-641, 2005