+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ PDF Full Text
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Adapting the innovation systems approach to agricultural development in Vietnam challenges to the public extension service

Adapting the innovation systems approach to agricultural development in Vietnam challenges to the public extension service

Agriculture and Human Values 30(4): 555-568

Competing models of innovation informing agricultural extension, such as transfer of technology, participatory extension and technology development, and innovation systems have been proposed over the last decades. These approaches are often presented as antagonistic or even mutually exclusive. This article shows how practitioners in a rural innovation system draw on different aspects of all three models, while creating a distinct local practice and discourse. We revisit and deepen the critique of Vietnam s model approach to upland rural development, voiced a decade ago in this journal. Our analysis of interviews with grassroots extension workers and extension managers reveals how they have received government, donor, and academic discourses on participation, user-orientation, and private sector involvement in innovation. Extension workers as well as managers integrate the reform discourses into the still-dominant transfer of technology model. We show how extensionists draw selectively on these diverse discourses to foster interaction with outsiders and clients, and bolster their livelihood strategies. We conclude that the conceptual framework suggested by the innovation systems (IS) approach is broadly appropriate for analyzing the Vietnamese case, but that the IS approach in the contemporary Vietnamese context requires adaptation for taking into account the blurred line between private and state sectors, and recognizing the hegemonic position of state-based networks. Improving extensionists ability to mediate between the conflicting principles of farmers self-organization and government control is identified as a key challenge for increasing innovative capacity in rural upland Vietnam.

(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 036789031

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

DOI: 10.1007/s10460-013-9433-y

Related references

Agricultural innovation for small farmers in the advisory and development service. An agricultural sociology investigation of the present situation of agricultural extension in developing countries, illustrated by the example of the National Food Crops Extension Programme in West Pasaman, Indonesia. Landwirtschaftliche Innovation fur Kleinbauern im Beratungs und Entwicklungsdienst Eine agrarsoziologische Untersuchung zum aktuellen Stand landwirtschaftlicher Beratung in Entwicklungslandern, dargestellt am Beispiel des National Food Crops Extension Programm NFCEP in West Pasaman,Indonesien: 319, 1980

Beyond agricultural innovation systems? Exploring an agricultural innovation ecosystems approach for niche design and development in sustainability transitions. Agricultural Systems 164: 116-121, 2018

Innovation system approach to agricultural development policy implications for agricultural extension delivery in Nigeria. African Journal Of Biotechnology: 11, 1604-1611, 2008

A systems approach to analysis of the agricultural extension service of Western Nigeria. 1971

Communication patterns in innovation development, extension and client system (a systems approach). Communication patterns in innovation development, extension and client system a systems approach: x + 336, 1986

Transforming the Roles of a Public Extension Agency to Strengthen Innovation: Lessons from the National Agricultural Extension Project in Bangladesh. The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 20(1): 7-25, 2014

Successful agricultural extension: its dependence upon other aspects of agricultural development. The case of public sector extension in North-east Africa. Agricultural extension worldwide: 75-88, 1987

Improving the output of agricultural extension and research through participatory innovation development and extension: experiences from Zimbabwe. European Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 2(4): 15-23, 1996

Student change agent: an innovation to agricultural extension service in Oyo state, Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Agricultural Teacher Education 1(1): 101-105, 1992

Technology development and adoption rates. Systems approach for agricultural research and extension. Food Policy 8(2): 141-153, 1983

Autonomous organization in the agricultural extension stations and in the organizations of the associated work in agriculture processing complex of SR Croatia; the special public interest of the extension service. Agronomski glasnik: 9 (1) 123-128, 1977

Report on the training course Improving the Utilization of Mobile Units in Agricultural Extension conducted by UNDP/Development Support Communication Service for staff of the Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives , March 14-April 1, 1977. Research Bulletin, United Nations Development Programme, Development Support Communication Service (344): 5, 1977

Agricultural biotechnology in Indonesia: new approach, innovation and challenges. Plant biotechnology transfer to developing countries: 97-116, 1995

A study of the agricultural extension service in the United States (North Carolina) and the agricultural extension service in Ghana. Dissertation Abstracts International, A Humanities and Social Sciences 48(4): p.811, 1987

Adapting a regularized canopy reflectance model (REGFLEC) for the retrieval challenges of dryland agricultural systems. Remote Sensing of Environment 186: 105-120, 2016