+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Rationality in flood risk management The limitations of probabilistic risk assessment PRA in the design and selection of flood protection strategies



Rationality in flood risk management The limitations of probabilistic risk assessment PRA in the design and selection of flood protection strategies







The introduction of new flood protection strategies prompts the need for a general framework for evaluating different flood protection strategies. The focus in this paper is on rationality in selecting between flood protection strategies; more particularly, on the question to what extent risk-based design and probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) can provide a general framework for rational evaluation of different flood protection strategies. On the basis of Arrow's impossibility theorem and the standard literature on cost-benefit analysis, the limitations of risk-based design and PRA are discussed. Applied to the context of flood risk management, it is shown that the problem of selecting between different flood protection strategies is susceptible to Arrow's impossibility theorem, which makes risk-based design seem less suitable as a generally applicable procedure. The incommensurability of criteria in the selection of flood protection strategies is related to the uncertainties pertaining to the different flood protection strategies. When selecting between strategies, risk-based design should therefore be complemented with other decision tools.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 036798669

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

DOI: 10.1111/jfr3.12044


Related references

Living with flood risk/The more we know, the more we know we don't know: Reflections on a decade of planning, flood risk management and false precision/Searching for resilience or building social capacities for flood risks?/Participatory floodplain management: Lessons from Bangladesh/Planning and retrofitting for floods: Insights from Australia/Neighbourhood design considerations in flood risk management/Flood risk management Challenges to the effective implementation of a paradigm shift. Planning Theory & Practice 14(1): 103-140, 2013

Flood management, flood risk assessment and flood plain zoning. Transactions of the 19th International Congress on Irrigation and Drainage, Beijing, China, 2005 Vol 1B: Harmonious coexistence with flood water: R3.02, 2005

Sharing the burden of increasing flood risk: who pays for flood insurance and flood risk management in the United Kingdom. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 20(6): 991-1009, 2015

Balancing flood risk and development in the flood plain: the Lower Thames Flood Risk Management Strategy. Ecohydrology and Hydrobiology 14(1): 33-38, 2014

Flood Safety versus Remaining Risks - Options and Limitations of Probabilistic Concepts in Flood Management. Water Resources Management 31(10): 3131-3145, 2017

Impact assessment of upstream flooding on extreme flood frequency analysis by incorporating a flood-inundation model for flood risk assessment. Journal of Hydrology 554: 370-382, 2017

Flood management and risk assessment in flood-prone areas: Measures and solutions. Irrigation and Drainage 60(2): 229-240, 2011

Flood Risks in Consequence of Agrarian Land-Use Measures in Flood FORMATION AND INUNDATION ZONES AND CONCLUSIONS FOR FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT PLANS. Irrigation and Drainage 60: 105-112, 2011

Strategic coastal flood-risk management in practice: Actors perspectives on the integration of flood risk management in London and the Thames Estuary. Ocean & Coastal Management 52(12): 636-645, 2009

Integrated application of the analytic hierarchy process and the geographic information system for flood risk assessment and flood plain management in Taiwan. Natural Hazards 59(3): 1261-1276, 2011

Urban flood risk analysis for determining optimal flood protection levels based on digital terrain model and flood spreading model. Visual Computer 26(11): 1369-1381, 2010

Improving flood risk analysis for effectively supporting the implementation of flood risk management plans: The case study of Serio Valley. Environmental Science & Policy 75: 158-172, 2017

Do flood risk perceptions provide useful insights for flood risk management? Findings from central Vietnam. Journal of Flood Risk Management aop(aop), 2012

Justice and flood risk management: reflecting on different approaches to distribute and allocate flood risk management in Europe. Natural Hazards 83(1): 129-147, 2016

From Flood Protection to Flood Risk Management: Condition-Based and Performance-Based Regulations in German Water Law. Journal of Environmental Law 26(2): 243-268, 2014