+ Site Statistics
References:
54,258,434
Abstracts:
29,560,870
PMIDs:
28,072,757
+ Search Articles
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ PDF Full Text
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Methods to explain the clinical significance of health status measures



Methods to explain the clinical significance of health status measures



Mayo Clinic Proceedings 77(4): 371-383



One can classify ways to establish the interpretability of quality-of-life measures as anchor based or distribution based. Anchor-based measures require an independent standard or anchor that is itself interpretable and at least moderately correlated with the instrument being explored. One can further classify anchor-based approaches into population-focused and individual-focused measures. Population-focused approaches are analogous to construct validation and rely on multiple anchors that frame an individual's response in terms of the entire population (eg, a group of patients with a score of 40 has a mortality of 20%). Anchors for population-based approaches include status on a single item, diagnosis, symptoms, disease severity, and response to treatment. Individual-focused approaches are analogous to criterion validation. These methods, which rely on a single anchor and establish a minimum important difference in change in score, require 2 steps. The first step establishes the smallest change in score that patients consider, on average, to be important (the minimum important difference). The second step estimates the proportion of patients who have achieved that minimum important difference. Anchors for the individual-focused approach include global ratings of change within patients and global ratings of differences between patients. Distribution-based methods rely on expressing an effect in terms of the underlying distribution of results. Investigators may express effects in terms of between-person standard deviation units, within-person standard deviation units, and the standard error of measurement. No single approach to interpretability is perfect. Use of multiple strategies is likely to enhance the interpretability of any particular instrument.

(PDF emailed within 1 workday: $29.90)

Accession: 046676498

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 11936935


Related references

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Relationship between Health Utility and Psychometric Health Status Measures. Medical Care 30(5): Ms274-Ms282, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || The Clinical Swiss Army Knife: Empirical Evidence on the Validity of IADL Functional Status Measures. Medical Care 30(5): Ms96-Ms111, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Using Health Status Measures in the Hospital Setting: From Acute Care to 'Outcomes Management'. Medical Care 30(5): Ms57-Ms73, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Methods for Assessing Condition-Specific and Generic Functional Status Outcomes after Total Knee Replacement. Medical Care 30(5): Ms240-Ms252, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Forces Motivating the Use of Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Settings and Related Clinical Research. Medical Care 30(5): Ms15-Ms22, 1992

The dynamics of income and neighborhood context for population health: do long-term measures of socioeconomic status explain more of the black/white health disparity than single-point-in-time measures?. Social Science and Medicine 68(8): 1368-1375, 2009

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Strategies for Improving and Expanding the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: General Audience Discussion. Medical Care 30(5): Ms210-Ms218, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Strategies for Improving and Expanding the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: A Researcher-Developer Viewpoint. Medical Care 30(5): Ms176-Ms186, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Strategies for Improving and Expanding the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Discussion. Medical Care 30(5): Ms196-Ms197, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Recent Developments and Future Issues in the Use of Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Settings. Medical Care 30(5): Ms23-Ms41, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Benefits and Obstacles for Development of Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Settings. Medical Care 30(5): Ms50-Ms56, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Patient-Based Health Status Measures in Outpatient Dialysis: Early Experiences in Developing an Outcomes Assessment Program. Medical Care 30(5): Ms136-Ms149, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Where Do We Go from Here? Opportunities for Applying Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Settings. Medical Care 30(5): Ms219-Ms230, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Applications of Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Practice: Overview of the Third Conference on Advances in Health Status Assessment. Medical Care 30(5): Ms1-Ms14, 1992

Supplement: Advances in Health Status Assessment: Fostering the Application of Health Status Measures in Clinical Settings: Proceedings of a Conference || Health Status Measurement: Implementation Strategies. Medical Care 30(5): Ms187-Ms195, 1992