+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Forced organ donation: the presumed consent to organ donation laws of the various states and the United States Constitution



Forced organ donation: the presumed consent to organ donation laws of the various states and the United States Constitution



Albany Law Journal of Science and Technology 9(349): 1-20



The issues presented in this Comment pertain to whether there are substantive limits imposed by the Fourteenth Amendment upon the state legislatures which would defeat the recent, tentative steps of many states to pass laws authorizing presumed consent to organ donation. The final and perhaps least effective presumed consent law creates a presumption of consent to organ donation. The potential organ donor makes the choice whether to donate or not during his lifetime. This form of the presumed consent law would probably have the least impact on increasing the number of available donor organs. It permitted the coroner to harvest the eyes and corneas of deceased individuals if the coroner was unaware of objections from either the decedent or the family of the decedent. Presumed consent statutes should be found unconstitutional because they infringe upon a family's property interest in a deceased relative's corpse. However, due to the family's property interest in a relative's deceased body, as set forth in the next section, the result is that presumed consent statutes are unconstitutional. In order to find the presumed consent law unconstitutional, the Court would have to find that either: (a) the Fourteenth Amendment's liberty component included the family's right to determine what happens to a relative's body after death, or (b) that the property component included a vested state law property interest in the dead body.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 1 workday: $29.90)

Accession: 049100516

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 16506330


Related references

Presumed consent for organ preservation in uncontrolled donation after cardiac death in the United States: a public policy with serious consequences. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 4: 15, 2010

The impact of presumed consent laws and institutions on deceased organ donation. European Journal of Health Economics 13(1): 29-38, 2012

Presumed consent organ donation in Pennsylvania: one small step for Pennsylvania, one giant leap for organ donation. Dickinson Law Review 107(4): 935-951, 2004

The impact of the presumed consent law and a decentralized organ procurement system on organ donation: quadruplication in the number of organ donors. Transplantation Proceedings 23(5): 2685-2686, 1991

Impact of presumed consent for organ donation on donation rates: a systematic review. BMJ 338: A3162, 2009

Living Organ Donation and Informed Consent in the United States: Strategies to Improve the Process. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 45(1): 66-76, 2018

The "new body snatchers": analyzing the effect of presumed consent organ donation laws on privacy, autonomy, and liberty. Fordham Urban Law Journal 28(3): 815-853, 2006

Decadal analysis of deceased organ donation in Spain and the United States linking an increased donation rate and the utilization of older donors. Liver Transplantation 19(9): 981-986, 2014

The Mississippi decision exchanging parole for kidney donation: is this the beginning of change for altruistic-based human organ donation policy in the United States?. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 86(5): 414-418, 2011

The transplantable organ shortage in Singapore: has implementation of presumed consent to organ donation made a difference?. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore 38(4): 346-348, 2009

Legislation of presumed consent for end-of-life organ donation in the United Kingdom (UK): undermining values in a multicultural society. Clinics 63(3): 297-300, 2008

Changing Metrics of Organ Procurement Organization Performance in Order to Increase Organ Donation Rates in the United States. American Journal of Transplantation 17(12): 3183-3192, 2017

Organ donation: the States refuse the implicit consent. Revue Medicale Suisse 9(409): 2310-2311, 2014

The Latin American population in Spain and organ donation. Attitude toward deceased organ donation and organ donation rates. Transplant International 28(4): 437-447, 2015

Presumed consent for organ donation. America 155(15): 326-327, 332, 1986