+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Treating competent patients by force: the limits and lessons of Israel's Patient's Rights Act



Treating competent patients by force: the limits and lessons of Israel's Patient's Rights Act



Journal of Medical Ethics 31(1): 29-34



Competent patients who refuse life saving medical treatment present a dilemma for healthcare professionals. On one hand, respect for autonomy and liberty demand that physicians respect a patient's decision to refuse treatment. However, it is often apparent that such patients are not fully competent. They may not adequately comprehend the benefits of medical care, be overly anxious about pain, or discount the value of their future state of health. Although most bioethicists are convinced that partial autonomy or marginal competence of this kind demands the same respect as full autonomy, Israeli legislators created a mechanism to allow ethics committees to override patients' informed refusal and treat them against their will. To do so, three conditions must be satisfied: physicians must make every effort to ensure the patient understands the risks of non-treatment, the treatment physicians propose must offer a realistic chance of significant improvement, and there are reasonable expectations that the patient will consent retroactively. Although not all of these conditions are equally cogent, they offer a way forward to assure care for certain classes of competent patients without abandoning the principle of autonomy altogether. These concerns reach past Israel and should engage healthcare professionals wary that respect for autonomy may sometimes cause avoidable harm.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 050829212

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 15634750

DOI: 10.1136/jme.2002.000877


Related references

Data on patients' rights: 1. "Your rights as a patient at Beth Israel Hospital, Boston"; 2. Declaration of patients' rights by the American Hospital Association; 3. Physicians' Manual by the Japanese Hospital Association; 4. Declaration of patients' rights by the Japanese Committee for Preparation of Declaration of Patients' Rights (a draft). Kangogaku Zasshi 50(1): 28-32, 1986

Patient accountability and quality of care: lessons from medical consumerism and the patients' rights, women's health and disability rights movements. American Journal of Law and Medicine 20(1-2): 147-167, 1994

Attitudes and practices of patients and physicians towards patient autonomy: a survey conducted prior to the enactment of the Patients' Rights Bill in Israel. Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics 10(4): 119-125, 2000

Medical ethics committees in Israel: implementing the Israel Patient Rights Act and terminating life-sustaining treatment. Israel Medical Association Journal 3(6): 461-464, 2001

Patient's Rights Law and Culturally Competent Nursing Care: An Israeli Perspective. Medicine and Law 33(3): 35-48, 2014

The limits of intellectual property rights lessons from the spread of illegal transgenic cotton seeds in India. Working Paper: 2, 34 22 Ref, 2008

The patient's right to know, in the 1996 Israel law for the rights of the patient: the pains of progress. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 37(2): 95, 2000

Patients' rights in England and the United States of America: The Patient's Charter and the New Jersey Patient Bill of Rights: a comparison. Journal of Medical Ethics 23(4): 213-220, 1997

The Society for Patient's Rights in Israel. Nursing Ethics 6(2): 167-172, 1999

The rights of the mental patient in Israel. Medicine and Law 3(4): 405-420, 1984

Carpe low-dose aspirin: the new anti-cancer face of an old anti-platelet drug. Platelets 29(8): 773-778, 2018

Judge allows force feeding of mentally competent patient. Bmj 309(6950): 291-292, 1994

Autonomy and paternalism in communitarian society. Patient rights in Israel. Hastings Center Report 29(4): 13-20, 1999

Treating non-competent patients. Bmj 331(7529): 1353-1354, 2005

Rethinking paternalism: an exploration of responses to the Israel Patient's Rights Act 1996. Journal of Medical Ethics 37(9): 540-543, 2011