+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

When computers should remain computers: a qualitative look at the humanization of health care technology

When computers should remain computers: a qualitative look at the humanization of health care technology

Health Informatics Journal 12(3): 239-254

This article describes users' responses to human-like characteristics of two health promotion IVR systems. We conducted a qualitative evaluation of two systems that promoted physical activity and healthy dietary behavior respectively. Two themes that emerged dealt with favorable responses of the users to the machine's intrinsic qualities of being insentient and non-judgmental, and the users' precarious sensitivity to certain human-like characteristics of the systems, namely, the content of the scripts and the recorded human voice. The article suggests that design factors that are intended to enhance human-like characteristics of these applications elicit both positive and negative responses. Thus, even though many users enjoyed and appreciated the human-like performance of the machine, some who were more sensitive about their exercise or dietary behavior preferred a non-affective response by these systems, i.e. they preferred the system to behave like a 'machine' (without emotions) rather than a 'person'.

Please choose payment method:

(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 050976008

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 17023411

DOI: 10.1177/1460458206066663

Related references

Strategies for the use of computers in health care. Symposium on information technology as a tool in health care. Linkoping, 27-28 October 1987. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 27(1): 95-100, 1988

Computers in case management. Advancing health care delivery through technology. Nursing Case Management 1(2): 59-61, 1996

Doctors, patients, and computers: will information technology dehumanize health-care delivery?. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 137(3): 390-398, 1993

True technology-enabled mental health care: when will we trust the computers and robots?. Mhealth 4: 10, 2018

Health care information technology and informed consent: computers and the doctor-patient relationship. Indiana Law Review 31(4): 1019-1042, 2001

Application of computers in diabetes care--a review. I. Computers for data collection and interpretation. Medical Informatics 20(4): 281-302, 1995

Application of computers in diabetes care-a review: II. Computers for decision support and education. Medical Informatics 20(4): 303-329, 1995

Health information technology and physician-patient interactions: impact of computers on communication during outpatient primary care visits. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association 13(2): 236; Author Reply 237-236; Author Reply 237, 2005

Improving Patient Health Outcomes in Acute Care Hospital Units Using Mobile Wireless Technology and Handheld Computers. Cin Computers Informatics Nursing 25(5): 308-309, 2007

Computers and the organization of medical care. What computers can and cannot do. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 184(1077): 375-378, 1973

International congress series 907 computers and perinatal medicine 2nd world symposium on computers in the care of the mother fetus and newborn kyoto japan october 23 26 1989. Maeda, K , M Hogaki And H Nakano International Congress Series, 907 Computers And Perinatal Medicine; 2nd World Symposium on Computers in The Care Of The Mother, Fetus And Newborn, Kyoto, Japan, October 23-26, 1989 Ix+258p Elsevier Science Publishers B V (Biomedical Division): Amsterdam, Netherlands; (Dist in The Usa And Canada By Elsevier Science Publishing Co Inc : New York, New York) Illus Ix+258p, 1990

Introduction of computers. 16. From home computers to large computers. Kangogaku Zasshi 46(4): 449-452, 1982

Effective use of computers. Part Two: Computers talking to computers. Journal of Healthcare Materiel Management 5(6): 80-81, 1987

Information technology: computers kill care. Nursing Standard 1987) 8(7): 42-43, 1993

Computers in critical care nursing: yet another technology?. Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing 5(6): 325-326, 1986