+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Are you being served? The inter-organizational status and job perception of those responsible for patient rights in general hospitals in Israel



Are you being served? The inter-organizational status and job perception of those responsible for patient rights in general hospitals in Israel



Harefuah 148(6): 395



Paragraph 25 of the Patient's Rights Law in Israel requires that every medical facility director in Israel appoint an Ombudsman who will be responsible for patients' rights, receive patient complaints and resolve them. The law aims to strengthen the patient's position vis-à-vis service providers. Therefore, it is desirable that the Ombudsman shall function independently without apprehension or bias. Eleven years after the law was legislated, the authors researched the following: Were individuals responsible for patient rights appointed in all general hospitals? Who are the position holders? What issues do they deal with? What is the weight of their various responsibilities concerning patient rights, as defined by the law, relative to their other tasks? Do they benefit from organizational mechanisms that assure their independence within the service provider's organization? How do they perceive their job--as "Patient Representatives" (as defined by law), or as representatives of their hospitals? Hence, the authors personally interviewed each of the 26 General Hospital Directors in Israel as well as the Ombudsmen in each of their facilities. In each of Israel's general hospitals, an Ombudsman responsible for patient rights was appointed. In the majority of cases (82.6%) the Ombudsman was also engaged in an additional managerial or staff position within the organization. As a result, the Ombudsmen are almost entirely dependent on hospital management. The necessary means, by which to fulfill their positions and responsibilities as defined by the law, such as instructing and guiding medical staff regarding the protection of patient rights, have yet to be put at their disposal. The majority of the Ombudsmen view themselves as management representatives. These perceptions do not agree with the spirit of the Patient's Rights Law which is meant to strengthen the patient's position vis-à-vis medical services providers. The authors found a correlation between these views and the fact that Ombudsmen simultaneously hold additional managerial positions and some see themselves as part of their hospitals senior organizational hierarchy. In addition, we found a correlation between their seniority within the organization and their identification with the organization. It is recommended that the independence of those responsible for patient rights be strengthened by adding specific stipulations to the law on this matter and that the necessary means needed to fulfill their responsibilities as legislated, be put at their disposal. The authors recommend promoting the independent status of Ombudsmen by not imposing upon them responsibilities other than those for patient rights.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 1 workday: $29.90)

Accession: 051632206

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 19902607


Related references

Adult general psychiatric patients served in Nebraska's state hospitals: patient characteristics and needs. Community Mental Health Journal 51(2): 198-203, 2015

Management of mycobacteriosis in general hospital without isolation ward for tuberculosis patients. 3. Current status of tuberculosis patient care in university hospitals and general hospitals in Japan. Kekkaku 74(2): 139-143, 1999

Incidence of isolation and antibiotic resistance of E. coli responsible for urinary infections outside hospitals, in specialized hospitals and in general hospitals. Pathologie-Biologie 32(5): 389-392, 1984

Medical ethics committees in Israel: implementing the Israel Patient Rights Act and terminating life-sustaining treatment. Israel Medical Association Journal 3(6): 461-464, 2001

Clinical team meetings of physicians and nurses to promote patient- centered medical care: Current status in obstetrics and gynecology ward of university or general hospitals and major women's hospitals in Japan and factors influencing the prevalence. Medical Journal of Kagoshima University 56(1): 13-19, 2004

The effects of introducing prospective payments to general hospitals on length of stay, quality of care, and hospitals' income: the early experience of Israel. Social Science and Medicine 55(6): 981-989, 2002

Data on patients' rights: 1. "Your rights as a patient at Beth Israel Hospital, Boston"; 2. Declaration of patients' rights by the American Hospital Association; 3. Physicians' Manual by the Japanese Hospital Association; 4. Declaration of patients' rights by the Japanese Committee for Preparation of Declaration of Patients' Rights (a draft). Kangogaku Zasshi 50(1): 28-32, 1986

Multi inter-organizational information systems: competitive strategies for teaching hospitals in the 1990s. Health Services Management Research 4(1): 53-64, 1991

The patient's right to know, in the 1996 Israel law for the rights of the patient: the pains of progress. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 37(2): 95-102, 2000

Organizational culture according to the perception of nursing service directors in hospitals of different ethnic groups. Revista Da Escola de Enfermagem Da U S P 35(3): 282-286, 2001

Organizational and technological problems in the adherence to the patient's rights. Problemy Sotsial'noi Gigieny Zdravookhraneniia i Istorii Meditsiny 2002(2): 32-35, 2002

Patient satisfaction, nutrient content and actual intake of food served in two Dublin teaching hospitals. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 57(4): 166A, 1998

How organizational learning is associated with patient rights: a qualitative content analysis. Global Health Action 9: 30939, 2016

The rights of the mental patient in Israel. Medicine and Law 3(4): 405-420, 1984

The Society for Patient's Rights in Israel. Nursing Ethics 6(2): 167-172, 1999