+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Brave New World versus Island--utopian and dystopian views on psychopharmacology



Brave New World versus Island--utopian and dystopian views on psychopharmacology



Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy 10(2): 119-128



Aldous Huxley's Brave New World is a famous dystopia, frequently called upon in public discussions about new biotechnology. It is less well known that 30 years later Huxley also wrote a utopian novel, called Island. This paper will discuss both novels focussing especially on the role of psychopharmacological substances. If we see fiction as a way of imagining what the world could look like, then what can we learn from Huxley's novels about psychopharmacology and how does that relate to the discussion in the ethical and philosophical literature on this subject? The paper argues that in the current ethical discussion the dystopian vision on psychopharmacology is dominant, but that a comparison between Brave New World and Island shows that a more utopian view is possible as well. This is illustrated by a discussion of the issue of psychopharmacology and authenticity. The second part of the paper draws some further conclusions for the ethical debate on psychopharmacology and human enhancement, by comparing the novels not only with each other, but also with our present reality. It is claimed that the debate should not get stuck in an opposition of dystopian and utopian views, but should address important issues that demand attention in our real world: those of evaluation and governance of enhancing psychopharmacological substances in democratic, pluralistic societies.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 051859818

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 17486431

DOI: 10.1007/s11019-007-9059-1


Related references

Dystopian anxieties versus utopian ideals: medicine from Frankenstein to The Visible Human Project and Body Worlds. Science As Culture 15(1): 61-84, 2006

Hans Jonas,Brave New World, and Utopian Business Ethics. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 29(5): 723-735, 2016

A healthbot future: utopian, dystopian, distraction?. Journal of Visual Communication in Medicine 40(1): 1, 2017

Diabetes and technology in 2030: a utopian or dystopian future?. Diabetic Medicine 35(4): 498-503, 2018

Discriminating utopian from dystopian literature: Why is walden two considered a dystopia?. Behavior Analyst 16(2): 167-175, 1993

The Dao of human cloning: utopian/dystopian hype in the British press and popular films. Public Understanding of Science 17(2): 123-143, 2008

The Dao of human cloning: utopian/dystopian hype in the British press and popular films. Public Understanding of Science 17(2): 123-143, 2009

Utopian Hopes or Dystopian Fears? Exploring the Motivational Underpinnings of Moralized Political Engagement. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 43(2): 177-190, 2016

The Cursed Channel: utopian and dystopian imaginations of landscape transformation in twentieth-century Hungary. Journal of Historical Geography 61: 1-13, 2018

Utopian visions/dystopian realities: exploring practice and taking action to enable human rights and occupational justice in a hospital context. Australian Occupational Therapy Journal 58(5): 378-385, 2012

The brave new world of GEC evaluation: the experience of the Rhode Island Geriatric Education Center. Gerontology and Geriatrics Education 33(3): 253-271, 2012

Two Different Views on the World Around Us: The World of Uniformity versus Diversity. Plos One 11(12): E0168589, 2017

Brave New Baby in the Brave New World. Women & Health 13(1-2): 149-153, 1988

Brave new baby in the brave new world. Women and Health 13(1-2): 149-153, 1987

A brave new animal for a brave new world: The British Laboratory Animals Bureau and the constitution of international standards of laboratory animal production and use, circa 1947-1968. Isis; An International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences 101(1): 62-94, 2010