+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Consumer-oriented health care reform strategies: a review of the evidence on managed competition and consumer-directed health insurance

Consumer-oriented health care reform strategies: a review of the evidence on managed competition and consumer-directed health insurance

Milbank Quarterly 87(4): 820-841

For many years, leading health care reform proposals have been based on market-oriented strategies. In the 1990s, a number of reform proposals were built around the concept of "managed competition," but more recently, "consumer-directed health care" models have received attention. Although price-conscious consumer demand plays a critical role in both the managed competition and consumer-directed health care models, the two strategies are based on different visions of the health care marketplace and the best way to use market forces to achieve greater systemwide efficiencies. This article reviews the research literature that tests the main hypotheses concerning the two policy strategies. Numerous studies provide consistent evidence that consumers' health plan choices are sensitive to out-of-pocket premiums. The elasticity of demand appears to vary with consumers' health risk, with younger, healthier individuals being more price sensitive. This heterogeneity increases the potential for adverse selection. Biased risk selection also is a concern when the menu of health plan options includes consumer-directed health plans. Several studies confirm that such plans tend to attract healthier enrollees. A smaller number of studies test the main hypothesis regarding consumer-directed health plans, which is that they result in lower medical spending than do more generous plans. These studies find little support for this claim. The experiences of employers that have adopted key elements of managed competition are generally consistent with the key hypotheses underlying that strategy. Research in this area, however, has focused on only a narrow range of questions. Because consumer-directed health care is such a recent phenomenon, research on this strategy is even more limited. Additional studies on both topics would be valuable.

Please choose payment method:

(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 052315107

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 20021587

DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0009.2009.00580.x

Related references

Consumer-Oriented Health Care Reform Strategies: A Review of the Evidence on Managed Competition and Consumer-Directed Health Insurance. The Milbank Quarterly 87(4): 820-841, 2009

Consumer Action in Health Care: The Past and Present of the Consumer Movement in Health Care, Modes of Consumer Participation, and Issues concerning Consumer Representation on State Regulatory Boards for the Health Professions. Public Health Reports (1974-) 91(5): 406-411, 1976

Consumer choice of social health insurance in managed competition. Health Expectations 6(4): 312-322, 2003

Managed competition and consumer price sensitivity in social health insurance. Journal of Health Economics 21(6): 1009-1029, 2002

Federal health care reform legislation establishes consumer protections, health insurance exchanges. North Carolina Medical Journal 71(3): 239-242, 2010

Adult-Oriented Health Reform and Children's Insurance and Access to Care: Evidence from Massachusetts Health Reform. Maternal and Child Health Journal 23(8): 1008-1024, 2019

Consumer-directed health care for persons under 65 years of age with private health insurance: United States, 2007. Nchs Data Brief: 1-8, 2009

From managed care to consumer health insurance: the fall and rise of Aetna. Health Affairs 23(2): 43-55, 2004

Consumer-directed health care: understanding its value in health care reform. Health Care Manager 29(1): 29-33, 2010

Reform and consumer-directed health care can benefit your revenue cycle. Revenue-CycleStrategist8(6):4, 2011

Competition in health care: Is "consumer choice" in the consumer's interest?. New England Journal of Medicine 305(21): 1280-1282, 1981

Consumer-directed teaching of health care professionals involved in the care of people with spinal cord injury: the Consumer-Professional Partnership Program. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing 39(5): 228-234, 2008


Consumer-directed health care? Yes. Consumer-connected? Maybe. Health Data Management 18(6): 28 30 32 Passim, 2010

Health care at a crossroads. How health savings accounts and consumer-driven health care are changing the face of health insurance. Texas Dental Journal 123(12): 1108-1115, 2006