+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Patients' gender affected physicians' clinical decisions when presented with standardized patients but not for matching paper patients



Patients' gender affected physicians' clinical decisions when presented with standardized patients but not for matching paper patients



Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 62(5): 527-541



To compare physicians' treatment and referral decisions for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) for standardized patients with matching paper patients. Sixty-seven physicians (38 family physicians and 29 orthopedic surgeons) performed blinded assessments of two standardized patients (one man and one woman) with moderate knee osteoarthritis and otherwise identical clinical scenarios differing only in gender, and consented to including their data. Standardized patients recorded physicians' recommendations (yes/no) to refer for, or perform, TKA. Sixty physicians provided their treatment recommendations to matching paper patients. Recommendation rates for both the male and the female standardized patients (67% and 32%, respectively) were lower compared with the matching paper patients (80% and 67%, respectively). Physicians were more likely to recommend TKA to a man than to a woman when presented with standardized patients (odds ratio, 4.2; 95% confidence interval [CI]=2.4-7.3; P<0.001). In contrast, patients' gender did not affect the same physicians' recommendations regarding referral for, or performing, TKA for the matching paper patients (odds ratio, 2.0; 95% CI=0.9-4.6; P=0.101). Unlike their treatment recommendations for standardized patients, the same physicians' treatment and referral decisions for paper patients were not influenced by patients' gender, suggesting that paper patients are not a sensitive method of assessing physician bias.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 054894601

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 19348978

DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2008.03.009


Related references

Effects of examinee gender, standardized-patient gender, and their interaction on standardized patients' ratings of examinees' interpersonal and communication skills. Academic Medicine 68(2): 153-157, 1993

How and when should physicians discuss clinical decisions with patients?. Journal of General Internal Medicine 12(6): 397-398, 1997

Clinical decisions presented to patients in hospital encounters: a cross-sectional study using a novel taxonomy. Bmj Open 8(1): E018042, 2018

Standardized patients: a new method to assess the clinical skills of physicians. Best Practices and Benchmarking in Healthcare 2(4): 174-177, 1997

Decision-making for patients with resectable breast cancer: individualized decisions for and by patients and their physicians. Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network 1(2): 189-196, 2003

A standardized clinical evaluation of patients affected by facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy: The FSHD clinical score. Muscle and Nerve 42(2): 213-217, 2010

When patients lack capacity: the roles that patients with terminal diagnoses would choose for their physicians and loved ones in making medical decisions. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 30(4): 342-353, 2005

Gender, sequence of cases and day effects on clinical skills assessment with standardized patients. Medical Education 33(7): 499-503, 1999

Comparisons of the perceived value by medical students of trained arthritis educators vs standardized patients, simulated patients and attending physicians in teaching the musculoskeletal examination. Arthritis & Rheumatism 40(9 Suppl. ): S71, 1997

Using standardized patients and standardized physicians to improve patient-care quality: results of a pilot study. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing 28(5): 198-204, 1997

Are male cancer patients more affected by losing their jobs than female patients? Gender as a moderator of the relationship between losing the job and well-being in a sample of Romanian cancer patients. Journal of BUON 22(5): 1345-1351, 2017

Impact of gender-age interaction on the outcome of ischemic stroke in an Italian cohort of patients treated according to a standardized clinical pathway. European Journal of Internal Medicine 24(8): 807-812, 2013

Physician aid in dying and the relief of patients' suffering: physicians' attitudes regarding patients' suffering and end-of-life decisions. Journal of Clinical Ethics 6(1): 62-67, 1995

Simulated patients vs. standardized patients in objective structured clinical examinations. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 70(5): 119, 2006

Are interpersonal skills ratings influenced by gender in a clinical skills assessment using standardized patients?. Advances in Health Sciences Education 6(3): 231-241, 2001