+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Decision making on organ donation: the dilemmas of relatives of potential brain dead donors

Decision making on organ donation: the dilemmas of relatives of potential brain dead donors

Bmc Medical Ethics 16(1): 64

This article is part of a study to gain insight into the decision-making process by looking at the views of the relatives of potential brain dead donors. Alongside a literature review, focus interviews were held with healthcare professionals about their role in the request and decision-making process when post-mortal donation is at stake. This article describes the perspectives of the relatives. A content-analysis of 22 semi-structured in-depth interviews with relatives involved in an organ donation decision. Three themes were identified: 'conditions', 'ethical considerations' and 'look back'. Conditions were: 'sense of urgency', 'incompetence to decide' and 'agreement between relatives'. Ethical considerations result in a dilemma for non-donor families: aiding people or protecting the deceased's body, especially when they do not know his/her preference. Donor families respect the deceased's last will, generally confirmed in the National Donor Register. Looking back, the majority of non-donor families resolved their dilemma by justifying their decision with external arguments (lack of time, information etc.). Some non-donor families would like to be supported during decision-making. The discrepancy between general willingness to donate and the actual refusal of a donation request can be explained by multiple factors, with a cumulative effect. Firstly, half of the participants (most non-donor families) stated that they felt that they were not competent to decide in such a crisis and they seem to struggle with utilitarian considerations against their wish to protect the body. Secondly, non-donor families refused telling that they did not know the deceased's wishes or contesting posthumous autonomy of the eligible. Thirdly, the findings emphasise the importance of Donor Registration, because it seems to prevent dilemmas in decision-making, at least for donor families. Discrepancies between willingness to consent to donate and refusal at the bedside can be attributed to an unresolved dilemma: aiding people or protect the body of the deceased. Non-donor families felt incompetent to decide. They refused consent for donation, since their deceased had not given any directive. When ethical considerations do not lead to an unambiguous answer, situational factors were pivotal. Relatives of unregistered eligible donors are more prone to unstable decisions. To overcome ambivalence, coaching during decision-making is worth investigation.

Please choose payment method:

(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 057562705

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 26383919

DOI: 10.1186/s12910-015-0057-1

Related references

Changing pattern of organ donation at a single center: are potential brain dead donors being lost to donation after cardiac death?. American Journal of Transplantation 10(11): 2536-2540, 2011

Decision making by relatives about brain death organ donation: an integrative review. Transplantation 93(12): 1196-1211, 2013

The decision-making process of parents regarding organ donation of their brain dead child: a Greek study. Social Science and Medicine 64(2): 439-450, 2006

Higher organ donation consent rates by relatives of potential uncontrolled donors versus potential controlled donors after death. Nephrology, Dialysis, Transplantation 27(11): 4219-4223, 2013

Changing Patterns of Organ Donation: Brain Dead Donors Are Not Being Lost by Donation After Circulatory Death. Transplantation 100(2): 446-450, 2016

Organ donation from brain-dead and circulatory-dead donors: single-institution experiences. Transplantation Proceedings 46(4): 1051-1053, 2015

Decision-making capacity and informed consent in living organ donation--difficult constellations in the psychosomatic and medico-ethical assessment of potential donors. Zeitschrift für Psychosomatische Medizin und Psychotherapie 49(2): 164-174, 2003

Organ donation from a brain-dead patient. Donor criteria, organ-preserving therapy and discussion with the relatives. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift 114(25): 998-1002, 1989

Organ donation Experiences from a donor hospital with suggestions for handling potential organ donors and their relatives. Tidsskrift for den Norske Laegeforening 112(25): 3190-3192, 1992

Causes of Failure during the Management Process from Identification of Brain-Dead Potential Organ Donors to Actual Donation in Korea: a 5-Year Data Analysis (2012-2016). Journal of Korean Medical Science 33(50): E326-E326, 2018

Successful organ donation from brain dead donors in a Chinese organ transplantation center. American Journal of Transplantation 11(10): 2247-2249, 2012

Organ transplantation from brain-dead donors--problems in medical institutions for organ donation. Nihon Shokakibyo Gakkai Zasshi 108(5): 729-734, 2012

Identifying dilemmas in caring for brain-dead organ donors in the OR. Aorn Journal 46(5): 943-946, 1987

Organ donation from recently deceased patients. Experiences from a donor hospital and suggestions for handling potential organ donors and their relatives. Tidsskrift for den Norske Laegeforening 112(25): 3190-3193, 1992

Myths about organ donation on health personnel, potential recipients and relatives of potential donors in a peruvian hospital: a qualitative study. Revista Peruana de Medicina Experimental Y Salud Publica 33(1): 83-91, 2018