+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Exploring resistance to implementation of welfare technology in municipal healthcare services - a longitudinal case study



Exploring resistance to implementation of welfare technology in municipal healthcare services - a longitudinal case study



Bmc Health Services Research 16(1): 657



Industrialized and welfare societies are faced with vast challenges in the field of healthcare in the years to come. New technological opportunities and implementation of welfare technology through co-creation are considered part of the solution to this challenge. Resistance to new technology and resistance to change is, however, assumed to rise from employees, care receivers and next of kin. The purpose of this article is to identify and describe forms of resistance that emerged in five municipalities during a technology implementation project as part of the care for older people. This is a longitudinal, single-embedded case study with elements of action research, following an implementation of welfare technology in the municipal healthcare services. Participants included staff from the municipalities, a network of technology developers and a group of researchers. Data from interviews, focus groups and participatory observation were analysed. Resistance to co-creation and implementation was found in all groups of stakeholders, mirroring the complexity of the municipal context. Four main forms of resistance were identified: 1) organizational resistance, 2) cultural resistance, 3) technological resistance and 4) ethical resistance, each including several subforms. The resistance emerges from a variety of perceived threats, partly parallel to, partly across the four main forms of resistance, such as a) threats to stability and predictability (fear of change), b) threats to role and group identity (fear of losing power or control) and c) threats to basic healthcare values (fear of losing moral or professional integrity). The study refines the categorization of resistance to the implementation of welfare technology in healthcare settings. It identifies resistance categories, how resistance changes over time and suggests that resistance may play a productive role when the implementation is organized as a co-creation process. This indicates that the importance of organizational translation between professional cultures should not be underestimated, and supports research indicating that focus on co-initiation in the initial phase of implementation projects may help prevent different forms of resistance in complex co-creation processes.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 057838985

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 27846834

DOI: 10.1186/s12913-016-1913-5


Related references

Development and implementation of an information management and information technology strategy for improving healthcare services: a case study. Journal of Healthcare Information Management 15(3): 261-285, 2001

Barriers to exchanging healthcare information in inter-municipal healthcare services: a qualitative case study. Bmc Medical Informatics and Decision Making 18(1): 92, 2018

Expansion of social welfare for old-age pensioners in a municipal district of Leipzig--1st results of a longitudinal study. Zeitschrift für die Gesamte Hygiene und ihre Grenzgebiete 26(2): 129-132, 1980

Exploring drivers and challenges in implementation of health promotion in community mental health services: a qualitative multi-site case study using Normalization Process Theory. Bmc Health Services Research 18(1): 36, 2018

Guiding healthcare technology implementation: a new integrated technology implementation model. Computers Informatics Nursing 33(3): 99, 2015

Exploring perceptions of healthcare professionals in the implementation of a new professional role of clinical telehealth coordinator within a university integrated healthcare network. Telemedicine Journal and E-Health 16(5): 614-619, 2010

The future of integrated healthcare systems. Case study: Presbyterian Healthcare Services. Healthcare Forum Journal 35(2): 51 53, 1992

Why are they reluctant to report? A study of the barriers to reporting to child welfare services among public dental healthcare personnel. Health and Social Care in the Community 27(4): 871-879, 2019

Exploring long term implementation of cognitive services in community pharmacies - a qualitative study. Pharmacy Practice 10(3): 151-158, 2012

Exploring the relationships between provision of welfare benefits advice and the health of elderly people: a longitudinal observational study and discussion of methodological issues. Health and Social Care in the Community 15(5): 454-463, 2007

The standpoint of professionals on the presence and demands of men on the healthcare services: perspectives for the analysis of the implementation of the Comprehensive Healthcare Policy for Men. Ciencia and Saude Coletiva 17(10): 2617-2626, 2012

Exploring changes in nursing students' attitudes towards the use of technology: A four-wave longitudinal panel study. Nurse Education Today 38: 101-106, 2016

Adaptive approaches to the implementation of new clinical services: a case study of neonatal ICU pharmacy services. Topics in Hospital Pharmacy Management 9(4): 58-72, 1990

An operational study on implementation of mobile primary healthcare services for seasonal migratory farmworkers, Turkey. Maternal and Child Health Journal 16(9): 1906-1912, 2012

Assessment of the Municipal Solid Waste Status of Implementation of Municipal Solid Waste Management Handling, Rules, 2 in the State of Madhya Pradesh, 28 - A case study. Waste Management and Research 29(5): 558-562, 2011