+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Initial implementation of the conversion from the energy-subtracted CT number to electron density in tissue inhomogeneity corrections: an anthropomorphic phantom study of radiotherapy treatment planning



Initial implementation of the conversion from the energy-subtracted CT number to electron density in tissue inhomogeneity corrections: an anthropomorphic phantom study of radiotherapy treatment planning



Medical Physics 42(3): 1378-1388



To achieve accurate tissue inhomogeneity corrections in radiotherapy treatment planning, the authors had previously proposed a novel conversion of the energy-subtracted computed tomography (CT) number to an electron density (ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion), which provides a single linear relationship between ΔHU and ρ(e) over a wide range of ρ(e). The purpose of this study is to present an initial implementation of the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion method for a treatment planning system (TPS). In this paper, two example radiotherapy plans are used to evaluate the reliability of dose calculations in the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion method. CT images were acquired using a clinical dual-source CT (DSCT) scanner operated in the dual-energy mode with two tube potential pairs and an additional tin (Sn) filter for the high-kV tube (80-140 kV/Sn and 100-140 kV/Sn). Single-energy CT using the same DSCT scanner was also performed at 120 kV to compare the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion method with a conventional conversion from a CT number to ρ(e) (Hounsfield units, HU-ρ(e) conversion). Lookup tables for ρ(e) calibration were obtained from the CT image acquisitions for tissue substitutes in an electron density phantom (EDP). To investigate the beam-hardening effect on dosimetric uncertainties, two EDPs with different sizes (a body EDP and a head EDP) were used for the ρ(e) calibration. Each acquired lookup table was applied to two radiotherapy plans designed using the XiO TPS with the superposition algorithm for an anthropomorphic phantom. The first radiotherapy plan was for an oral cavity tumor and the second was for a lung tumor. In both treatment plans, the performance of the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion was superior to that of the conventional HU-ρ(e) conversion in terms of the reliability of dose calculations. Especially, for the oral tumor plan, which dealt with dentition and bony structures, treatment planning with the HU-ρ(e) conversion exhibited apparent discrepancies between the dose distributions and dose-volume histograms (DVHs) of the body-EDP and head-EDP calibrations. In contrast, the dose distributions and DVHs of the body-EDP and head-EDP calibrations coincided with each other almost perfectly in the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion for 100-140 kV/Sn. The difference between the V100's (the mean planning target volume receiving 100% of the prescribed dose; a DVH parameter) of the body-EDP and head-EDP calibrations could be reduced to less than 1% using the ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion, but exceeded 11% for the HU-ρ(e) conversion. The ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion can be implemented for currently available TPS's without any modifications or extensions. The ΔHU-ρ(e) conversion appears to be a promising method for providing an accurate and reliable inhomogeneity correction in treatment planning for any ill-conditioned scans that include (i) the use of a calibration EDP that is nonequivalent to the patient's body tissues, (ii) a mismatch between the size of the patient and the calibration EDP, or (iii) a large quantity of high-density and high-atomic-number tissue structures.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 058122392

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 25735292

DOI: 10.1118/1.4908207


Related references

Technical Note: exploring the limit for the conversion of energy-subtracted CT number to electron density for high-atomic-number materials. Medical Physics 41(7): 071701, 2014

Effect of computed tomography number-relative electron density conversion curve on the calculation of radiotherapy dose and evaluation of Monaco radiotherapy treatment planning system. Australasian Physical and Engineering Sciences in Medicine 42(2): 489-502, 2019

Simulation of photon-counting detectors for conversion of dual-energy-subtracted computed tomography number to electron density. Radiological Physics and Technology 12(1): 105-117, 2019

Conversion of the energy-subtracted CT number to electron density based on a single linear relationship: an experimental verification using a clinical dual-source CT scanner. Physics in Medicine and Biology 58(9): N135-N144, 2013

Validation of a radiotherapy treatment planning system using an anthropomorphic phantom and MTS-N thermoluminescent detectors. Radiation Protection Dosimetry 101(1-4): 477-480, 2002

In vivo proton dosimetry using a MOSFET detector in an anthropomorphic phantom with tissue inhomogeneity. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 13(2): 3699, 2012

Electron dose distributions in an anthropomorphic phantom--verification of Theraplan treatment planning algorithm. Medical Dosimetry 13(3): 155-158, 1988

The electron density of bone for inhomogeneity correction in radiotherapy planning using CT numbers. Physics in Medicine and Biology 29(4): 351-359, 1984

Simultaneous characterization of electron density and effective atomic number for radiotherapy planning using stoichiometric calibration method and dual energy algorithms. Australasian Physical and Engineering Sciences in Medicine 41(3): 601-619, 2018

Tolerance levels of CT number to electron density table for photon beam in radiotherapy treatment planning system. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 19(1): 271-275, 2018

Measurement of electron density and effective atomic number by dual-energy scan using a 320-detector computed tomography scanner with raw data-based analysis: a phantom study. Journal of Computer Assisted Tomography 38(6): 824-827, 2015

Estimation of electron density, effective atomic number and stopping power ratio using dual-layer computed tomography for radiotherapy treatment planning. Physica Medica 56: 34-40, 2018

Comparative role of three-dimensional radiotherapy planning and inhomogeneity corrections in carcinoma of the tongue. Australasian Radiology 41(2): 143-147, 1997

The dependence of computed tomography number to relative electron density conversion on phantom geometry and its impact on planned dose. Australasian Physical and Engineering Sciences in Medicine 37(2): 385-391, 2014

Investigation of a CT value electron density conversion method in radiotherapy planning CT. Nihon Hoshasen Gijutsu Gakkai Zasshi 63(8): 888-894, 2007