+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

The Buffalo Model: Shifting the Focus of Clinical Licensure Exams in Dentistry to Address Ethical Concerns Regarding Patient Care



The Buffalo Model: Shifting the Focus of Clinical Licensure Exams in Dentistry to Address Ethical Concerns Regarding Patient Care



Journal of Dental Education 80(6): 641-647



Most jurisdictions grant dental licensure to graduating students following successful completion of a clinical exam. Testing agencies, which are independent of dental schools, nevertheless conduct their exams at school facilities. Patient participation in these exams raises ethical concerns regarding such issues as unlicensed providers' performing irreversible procedures with minimal supervision and graduates' limited accessibility to provide follow-up treatment. To address these concerns, a collaborative effort between University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine faculty and testing agency personnel was launched. The aims of this article are to describe the development and implementation of the resulting Buffalo Model, to highlight ethical advantages in its application, and to identify areas of improvement to be addressed in future iterations. With the Buffalo Model, modifications were made to the traditional exam format in order to integrate the exam into the school curriculum, enabling candidates to take it at various points during their fourth year. In addition, after calibration of school faculty members, 98.5% of cases verified by faculty were accepted by the Commission on Dental Competency Assessments for use in the exam. In two cases, restorative treatment completed during the exam did not meet the school's competency standard. This new approach ameliorates ethical concerns associated with clinical licensure exams because treatment is provided only to patients of record within a sequenced treatment plan and timely and appropriate treatment is provided to all patients. The results of this first year of implementation also suggest that calibrated faculty members will not show bias in the selection of lesions or competency evaluations of candidates.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 1 workday: $29.90)

Accession: 058994011

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 27251344


Related references

Should Live Patient Licensing Examinations in Dentistry Be Discontinued? Two Viewpoints: Viewpoint 1: Alternative Assessment Models Are Not Yet Viable Replacements for Live Patients in Clinical Licensure Exams and Viewpoint 2: Ethical and Patient Care Concerns About Live Patient Exams Require Full Acceptance of Justifiable Alternatives. Journal of Dental Education 82(3): 246-251, 2018

Ethical obligations and concerns when trying to achieve a patient's wishes: palliative care clinical nurse specialist. Jona's Healthcare Law Ethics and Regulation 10(3): 77-79, 2008

On Our Way to Licensure: Perspectives on Live Patient Exams. Northwest Dentistry 95(4): 15 17 19-1520 22-3, 2016

Non-Patient-Based Clinical Licensure Examination for Dentistry in Minnesota: Significance of Decision and Description of Process. Journal of Dental Education 80(6): 648-651, 2016

Overview of state credentialing concerns: a focus on licensure. Therapeutic Recreation Journal 24(2): 40-59, 1990

Patient care. Florida governor to meet AHF to address concerns. Aids Policy & Law 22(14): 1-1, 2007

What the available evidence on clinical licensure exams shows. Journal of Evidence-Based Dental Practice 6(1): 148-154, 2006

Clinical licensure exams: the unruly gatekeepers. Journal of the American College of Dentists 72(3): 16-18, 2005

Ethics Standards (HRPP) and Public Partnership (PARTAKE) to Address Clinical Research Concerns in India: Moving Toward Ethical, Responsible, Culturally Sensitive, and Community-Engaging Clinical Research. Journal of Clinical Research and Bioethics 5(5): 195, 2014

Introduction and ethical concerns in the optometric care of the AIDS patient. Optometry and Vision Science 72(5): 293-293, 1995

Evaluation of a Novel Financial Navigator Pilot to Address Patient Concerns about Medical Care Costs. Permanente Journal 23:, 2019

Ethical dilemma: Retrieving semen from a dead patient Utilitarianism in the absence of definitive guidelines The patient was assaulted Some ethical concerns were ignored An ethic of ambivalence. BMJ 317(7172): 1583-1585, 1998

New care model targets high-utilizing, complex patients, frees up emergency providers to focus on acute care concerns. Ed Management 25(11): 125-127, 2014

Patient-centered medical home: improving health care by shifting the focus to patients. Connecticut Medicine 73(8): 479-480, 2009

Patient shifting between inpatient care and ambulatory care - exploring methods to measure the relevance of patient shifting. Gesundheitswesen ) 73(3): 124-133, 2011