+ Most Popular
Cunninghamia lanceolata plantations in China
Mammalian lairs in paleo ecological studies and palynology
Studies on technological possibilities in utilization of anhydrous milk fat for production of recombined butter-like products
Should right-sided fibroelastomas be operated upon?
Large esophageal lipoma
Apoptosis in the mammalian thymus during normal histogenesis and under various in vitro and in vivo experimental conditions
Poissons characoides nouveaux ou non signales de l'Ilha do Bananal, Bresil
Desensitizing efficacy of Colgate Sensitive Maximum Strength and Fresh Mint Sensodyne dentifrices
Administration of fluid by subcutaneous infusion: revival of a forgotten method
Tundra mosquito control - an impossible dream?
Schizophrenia for primary care providers: how to contribute to the care of a vulnerable patient population
Geochemical pattern analysis; method of describing the Southeastern limestone regional aquifer system
Incidence of low birth weights in a hospital of Mexico City
Graded management intensity of grassland systems for enhancing floristic diversity
Microbiology and biochemistry of cheese and fermented milk
The ember tetra: a new pygmy characid tetra from the Rio das Mortes, Brazil, Hyphessobrycon amandae sp. n. (Pisces, Characoidei)
Risk factors of contrast-induced nephropathy in patients after coronary artery intervention
Renovation of onsite domestic wastewater in a poorly drained soil
Observations of the propagation velocity and formation mechanism of burst fractures caused by gunshot
Systolic blood pressure in a population of infants in the first year of life: the Brompton study
Haematological studies in rats fed with metanil yellow
Studies on pasteurellosis. I. A new species of Pasteurella encountered in chronic fowl cholera
Dormancy breaking and germination of Acacia salicina Lindl. seeds
therapy of lupus nephritis. a two-year prospective study

Comparing sensitivity estimates from MLDS and forced-choice methods in a slant-from-texture experiment

Comparing sensitivity estimates from MLDS and forced-choice methods in a slant-from-texture experiment

Journal of Vision 17(1): 37

ISSN/ISBN: 1534-7362

PMID: 28135347

DOI: 10.1167/17.1.37

Maximum likelihood difference scaling (MLDS) is a method for the estimation of perceptual scales based on the judgment of differences in stimulus appearance (Maloney & Yang, 2003). MLDS has recently also been used to estimate near-threshold discrimination performance (Devinck & Knoblauch, 2012). Using MLDS as a psychophysical method for sensitivity estimation is potentially appealing, because MLDS has been reported to need less data than forced-choice procedures, and particularly naive observers report to prefer suprathreshold comparisons to JND-style threshold tasks. Here we compare two methods, MLDS and two-interval forced-choice (2-IFC), regarding their capability to estimate sensitivity assuming an underlying signal-detection model. We first examined the theoretical equivalence between both methods using simulations. We found that they disagreed in their estimation only when sensitivity was low, or when one of the assumptions on which MLDS is based was violated. Furthermore, we found that the confidence intervals derived from MLDS had a low coverage; i.e., they were too narrow, underestimating the true variability. Subsequently we compared MLDS and 2-IFC empirically using a slant-from-texture task. The amount of agreement between sensitivity estimates from the two methods varied substantially across observers. We discuss possible reasons for the observed disagreements, most notably violations of the MLDS model assumptions. We conclude that in the present example MLDS and 2-IFC could equally be used to estimate sensitivity to differences in slant, with MLDS having the benefit of being more efficient and more pleasant, but having the disadvantage of unsatisfying coverage.

Please choose payment method:

(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 059526614

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

Related references

Perceptual independence of pitch and loudness in a signal detection experiment a processing model for 2 alternative temporal forced choice 21 forced choice experiments. Perception and Psychophysics 17(6): 525-531, 1975

Comparing the validity of trait estimates from the multidimensional forced-choice format and the rating scale format. Psychological Assessment 32(3): 239-253, 2020

Some observations on the effects of slant and texture type on slant-from-texture. Vision Research 44(13): 1511-1535, 2004

Developing Bayesian adaptive methods for estimating sensitivity thresholds (d') in Yes-No and forced-choice tasks. Frontiers in Psychology 6: 1070, 2015

Comparing perceptual and visuo-motor accuracy for binocular estimates of surface slant. IOVS Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science 40(4): S374, 1999

Effect of Soil Texture on Estimates of Soil-Column Carbon Dioxide Flux Comparing Chamber and Gradient Methods. Vadose Zone Journal 17(1): 180112, 2018

Estimates of Spatial Prices in India and Their Sensitivity to Alternative Estimation Methods and Choice of Commodities. Social Indicators Research 131(1): 145-167, 2017

An experiment on the assessment of brightness under free-choice and forced-choice conditions by a group of observers. Ergonomics 3(1): 44-50, 1960

The Effect of Forced Choice with Constant Choice Experiment Complexity. Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 44(2): 439-455, 2019

Comparing Traditional and IRT Scoring of Forced-Choice Tests. Applied Psychological Measurement 39(8): 598-612, 2015

A forced-choice remote-viewing experiment. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 55(814): 275-278, 1989

The variance of d' estimates obtained in yes-no and two-interval forced choice procedures. Perception and Psychophysics 67(1): 72-80, 2005

Multiple texture cues are integrated for perception of 3D slant from texture. Journal of Vision 20(7): 14, 2020

Statistical properties of staircase estimates from two interval forced choice experiments. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 38(1): 35-43, 1985

The variance ofd estimates obtained in yesno and two-interval forced choice procedures. Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics 67(1): 72-80, 2005