+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Should Live Patient Licensing Examinations in Dentistry Be Discontinued? Two Viewpoints: Viewpoint 1: Alternative Assessment Models Are Not Yet Viable Replacements for Live Patients in Clinical Licensure Exams and Viewpoint 2: Ethical and Patient Care Concerns About Live Patient Exams Require Full Acceptance of Justifiable Alternatives



Should Live Patient Licensing Examinations in Dentistry Be Discontinued? Two Viewpoints: Viewpoint 1: Alternative Assessment Models Are Not Yet Viable Replacements for Live Patients in Clinical Licensure Exams and Viewpoint 2: Ethical and Patient Care Concerns About Live Patient Exams Require Full Acceptance of Justifiable Alternatives



Journal of Dental Education 82(3): 246-251



This Point/Counterpoint article addresses a long-standing but still-unresolved debate on the advantages and disadvantages of using live patients in dental licensure exams. Two contrasting viewpoints are presented. Viewpoint 1 supports the traditional use of live patients, arguing that other assessment models have not yet been demonstrated to be viable alternatives to the actual treatment of patients in the clinical licensure process. This viewpoint also contends that the use of live patients and inherent variances in live patient treatment represent the realities of daily private practice. Viewpoint 2 argues that the use of live patients in licensure exams needs to be discontinued considering those exams' ethical dilemmas of exposing patients to potential harm, as well as their lack of reliability and validity and limited scope. According to this viewpoint, the current presence of viable alternatives means that the risk of harm inherent in live patient exams can finally be eliminated and those exams replaced with other means to confirm that candidates are qualified for licensure to practice.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 065511978

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 29496802

DOI: 10.21815/jde.018.023


Related references

The Buffalo Model: Shifting the Focus of Clinical Licensure Exams in Dentistry to Address Ethical Concerns Regarding Patient Care. Journal of Dental Education 80(6): 641-647, 2016

On Our Way to Licensure: Perspectives on Live Patient Exams. Northwest Dentistry 95(4): 15 17 19-1520 22-3, 2016

The ethics of live patient use in dental hygiene clinical licensure examinations: a national survey. Journal of Dental Education 76(6): 667-681, 2012

The standardized live patient and mechanical patient models--their roles in trauma teaching. Journal of Trauma 66(1): 98, 2009

Live donor champion: finding live kidney donors by separating the advocate from the patient. Transplantation 93(11): 1147-1150, 2012

"It's Not Like You Need to Live 10 or 20 Years": Challenges to Patient-Centered Care in Gynecologic Oncologist-Patient Interactions. Qualitative Health Research 26(9): 1191-1202, 2016

Comparing the standardized live trauma patient and the mechanical simulator models in the ATLS initial assessment station. Journal of Surgical Research 162(1): 7, 2010

The cancer patient--a chronically ill patient. The care of seriously ill patients from the nursing viewpoint. Deutsche Krankenpflegezeitschrift 44(1): 29-33, 1991

Ethical dilemmas. When a frail elderly patient wants to live alone. Advance for Nurse Practitioners 5(7): 50-52, 1997

The psychological situation of the patient with long-term artificial respiration: from the viewpoint of the patient--possibilities and limitations of assistance from the viewpoint of the nurses. Krankenpflege Journal 27(4): 122-129, 1989

Surgical teaching in urology: patient safety and educational value of 'LIVE' and 'SEMI-LIVE' surgical demonstrations. World Journal of Urology 36(10): 1673-1679, 2018

Live or let die: ethical issues in a psychiatric patient with end-stage renal failure. Annals of the Academy of Medicine Singapore 38(4): 370-374, 2009

Ethics of using live patients for licensing board examinations. Journal of the American Dental Association 149(2): 163-164, 2018

A comparison of videotaped and live patient interview examinations and written examination in psychiatry. American Journal of Psychiatry 134(10): 1093-1097, 1977

Banning live patients as test subjects on licensing examinations. Journal of Dental Education 66(5): 605-9; Discussion 610-1, 2002