+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Technical note: Comparing 4 techniques for estimating desired grass species composition in horse pastures



Technical note: Comparing 4 techniques for estimating desired grass species composition in horse pastures



Journal of Animal Science 96(6): 2219-2225



Many methods exist for estimating species composition, but few studies compare those useful in improved horse pastures. The objective of this study was to examine 4 techniques for estimating desirable forage species composition in 2 cool-season horse pastures based on prevalence estimates, repeatability, bias, and practicality, and to select a method for use in a subsequent grazing study. The techniques included Equine Pasture Evaluation Disc (EPED), Line-Point Intercept with 3 transects of 50 observations each (LPI 3-50), LPI with 5 transects of 30 observations each (LPI 5-30), and Step Point (StPt). A generalized linear-mixed effects model procedure of SAS (GLIMMIX) with a logit link was used to test for differences among each species separately. When methods were significantly different (α = 0.05), pairwise comparisons were performed using a paired t-test. The methods did not differ in detecting creeping bentgrass (P = 0.3334) or orchardgrass (P = 0.4207), but there were differences for Kentucky bluegrass (P = 0.0082), tall fescue (P = 0.0314), and other (P = 0.0448). Repeatability plots displayed lower method repeatability as species prevalence increased. Agreement was analyzed between pairs of methods by grass species. Five out of 30 pairs showed significant overall bias (P = 0.0114, 0.0045, 0.0170, 0.0328, and 0.0404), and 3 of them were between LPI 3-50 and EPED. The LPI 3-50 and LPI 5-30 techniques agreed perfectly in prevalence and bias, as did StPt and EPED, meaning they can be used interchangeably. The techniques LPI 3-50 and EPED were the most dissimilar methods. In conclusion, StPt can be used interchangeably with LPI, but StPt was selected due to its thorough representation of the pastures and ease of use.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 065561231

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 29668994

DOI: 10.1093/jas/sky111


Related references

A study on feeding, reproduction, meat and milk products, disease and genetics for the development of the Cheju horse industry. I. Monthly changes in herbage production comparing new pastures of the horse farm with old pastures. Journal of the Korean Society of Grassland Science 16(1): 61-68, 1996

Technical note concerning different pastures of Pangola grass and Neonotonia wightii on milk production. Pastos y Forrajes 6(2): 255-261, 1983

Technical note on the comparison of various crossing techniques in Guinea grass (Panicum maximum Jacq.). Pastos y Forrajes 8(1): 45-52, 1985

Using microhistological techniques to predict botanical composition of horse diets on cool-season grass pasture. Multifunctional Grasslands In A Changing World, Volume 1: Xxi International Grassland Congress And Viii International Rangeland Congress, Hohhot, China, 29 E 5 Y: 3, 2008

Effects of freezing and drying grass products prior to fatty acid extraction on grass fatty acid and lipid class composition--a technical note. Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences 69(1): 93, 2004

Montane and subalpine mat grass pastures of the Schattberg region (Province of Salzburg): species composition and biomass. Bodenkultur 45(2): 99-112, 1994

Performance of lambs on perennial rye grass smooth brome grass orchard grass and tall fescue pastures part 2 mineral utilization in vitro digestibility and chemical composition of herbage. Journal of Animal Science 46(6): 1503-1514, 1978

The effect of phosphate and nitrogen fertilizing on yield and chemical composition of some grass species and white clover in pastures.. Forskn. Fors. Landbr 11: 203-253, 1960

The possibility of estimating fertilization needs of meadow soils from the chemical composition of certain grass species. Rocz Nauk Rolnicz Ser F 71(4): 1003-1044, 1956

Technical note: A comparison of techniques for extracting monoterpenoids from Juniperus (Cupressaceae) species. Journal of range management 51(5): 540-544, 1998

Technical Note: Collection and preparation techniques change nutrient composition of masticate collected from esophageally fistulated cattle. Journal of Animal Science 93(12): 5774-5780, 2015

Influence of the density of scattered trees in pastures on the structure and species composition of tree and grass cover in southern Tabasco, Mexico. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 232: 1-8, 2016

The possibility of estimating manurial requirements of meadow soils from the chemical composition of certain grass species.. Roczn. Nauk rol, 71F: 1003-1044, 1956

Technical note: Estimating body weight and body composition of beef cattle trough digital image analysis. Journal of Animal Science 94(12): 5414-5422, 2016

Effect of fertilizers on the mineral composition of grass and legume-grass stands on cultivated pastures. Khimiia v sel'skom khoziaistve6(4): 16-21, 1978