+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Using production-cost analysis to understand the competitiveness of sugarcane production: a comparison among Thailand, Vietnam, South Africa and Brazil



Using production-cost analysis to understand the competitiveness of sugarcane production: a comparison among Thailand, Vietnam, South Africa and Brazil



International Sugar Journal 119(1418): 134-139



The liberalization of sugar markets, along with lower logistic costs, has led to higher competition among sugar exporters. Understanding the differences in production systems and costs helps to identify competitive advantages and to understand future trends in the sugarcane production sector. The agri benchmark typical farm approach was used to analyze production systems and calculate sugarcane production costs of typical farms in Thailand, South Africa, Vietnam and Brazil. To ensure international comparability, the data was collected by national partners in an internationally consistent manner through focus-group discussions. The groups were composed of growers, extension agents and consultants, for the 2013 and 2014 seasons. All analyzed sugarcane farms show medium-term profitability as revenues cover the cash costs and depreciation. Nonetheless, the production costs differ substantially among farms. Results show that total cost per tonne of sugarcane (measured in recoverable sugar) are 150 USD/t lower on the typical Brazilian farm (Goiatuba) than on the other farms; this is mainly due to low operating costs. Conversely, the cost disadvantages for the typical Thai farm are mainly driven by operating costs (i.e. machinery), which are more than 100 USD/t higher than the Goiatuba (BR) farm. This is a result of insufficient economics of scale, as expensive machinery investments are under-utilized on low acreage farms. The Vietnamese farm has a high production cost but is still profitable due to significantly higher output prices. Possible drivers for the differences in production costs are the duration of the sugarcane cycle and yield levels that favor Brazil and South Africa. Size and operation scheme (contractor versus own machinery) play an important role in a farm's performance. The findings indicate that the approach of using typical sugarcane farms in major production areas helps to understand competitive advantages, identify production processes to be improved and enables knowledge transfer.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 1 workday: $29.90)

Accession: 066328738

Download citation: RISBibTeXText


Related references

Predicting climate change impacts on sugarcane production at sites in Australia, Brazil and South Africa using the Canegro model. International Sugar Journal 115(1380): 874-881, 2013

Searching for comparative advantage in commercial sugarcane production in South Africa: a pam analysis. Agrekon 39(2): 161-173, 2000

Competitiveness of poultry and pig production in Vietnam: an application of policy analysis matrix. Quarterly Journal of International Agriculture 43(2): 177-191, 2004

Comparative analysis of operational cost and the demand for production factors in the growing of sugarcane in the regions of Piracicaba and Ribeirao Preto, Sao Paulo State, Brazil, 1978. Informacoes economicas 8(8): 1-9, 1978

Economic analysis of sugarcane production systems based on raw material quality Production costs and statistics, Brazil.1. Brasil acucareiro 100(3-5): 28-44, 1982

Production of sugarcane in South Africa. South African Sugar Journal 58(5): 243-245, 1974

Sugarcane production in South Africa. Bulletin (1): 44, 1977

The role of potassium in the production of sugarcane in South Africa. Switzerland, International Potash Institute; South Africa, Fertilizer Society of South Africa: The role of potassium in crop production: 109-114, 1980

The role of phosphorus in the production of sugarcane in South Africa. Phosphorus in agriculture 34(78): 23-32, 1980

Environments for the production of sugarcane in the Central-South region of Brazil. Encarte Tenico Informacoes Agronomicas (110): 12-17, 2005

Effect of nematodes on the sustained production of sugarcane in South Africa. Field Crops Research 83(1): 91-100, 20 June, 2003

Impact of sugarcane production on South Africa's water resources studies. SA Waterbulletin 25(3): 16-18, 1999

The roles of nitrogen phosphorus and potassium in the production of sugarcane in south africa. Fertilizer Research 26(1-3): 89-98, 1990

A systems approach to benchmarking for sugarcane production in Australia and South Africa. Proceedings of the Annual Congress South African Sugar Technologists' Association ( 72): 3-9, 1998

Improving sugarcane production in frost-prone environments of South Africa. International Sugar Journal 118(1407): 222-228, 2016