+ Site Statistics
+ Search Articles
+ PDF Full Text Service
How our service works
Request PDF Full Text
+ Follow Us
Follow on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Follow on LinkedIn
+ Subscribe to Site Feeds
Most Shared
PDF Full Text
+ Translate
+ Recently Requested

Prevalence of Disagreement About Appropriateness of Treatment Between ICU Patients/Surrogates and Clinicians



Prevalence of Disagreement About Appropriateness of Treatment Between ICU Patients/Surrogates and Clinicians



Chest 155(6): 1140-1147



ICU patients/surrogates may experience adverse outcomes related to perceived inappropriate treatment. The objective was to determine the prevalence of patient/surrogate-reported perceived inappropriate treatment, its impact on adverse outcomes, and discordance with clinicians. We conducted a multicenter, prospective, observational study of adult ICU patients. For 151 patients, 1,332 patient, surrogate, nurse, and physician surveys were collected. Disagreement between patients/surrogates and clinicians regarding "too much" treatment being administered occurred in 26% of patients. Disagreement regarding "too little" treatment occurred in 10% of patients. Disagreement about perceived inappropriate treatment was associated with prognostic discordance (P = .02) and lower patient/surrogate satisfaction (Likert scale 1-5 of 4 vs 5; P = .02). Patient/surrogate respondents reported "too much" treatment in 8% of patients and "too little" treatment in 6% of patients. Perceived inappropriate treatment was associated with moderate or high respondent distress for 55% of patient/surrogate respondents and 35% of physician/nurse respondents (P = .30). Patient/surrogate perception of inappropriate treatment was associated with lower satisfaction (Family Satisfaction in the ICU Questionnaire-24, 69.9 vs 86.6; P = .002) and lower trust in the clinical team (Likert scale 1-5 of 4 vs 5; P = .007), but no statistically significant differences in depression (Patient Health Questionnaire-2 of 2 vs 1; P = .06) or anxiety (Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 Scale of 7 vs 4; P = .18). For approximately one-third of ICU patients, there is disagreement between clinicians and patients/surrogates about the appropriateness of treatment. Disagreement about appropriateness of treatment was associated with prognostic discordance and lower patient/surrogate satisfaction. Patients/surrogates who reported inappropriate treatment also reported lower satisfaction and trust in the ICU team.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 066635512

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

PMID: 30922949

DOI: 10.1016/j.chest.2019.02.404


Related references

Patient and surrogate disagreement in end-of-life decisions: can surrogates accurately predict patients' preferences?. Medical Decision Making 28(4): 524-531, 2008

Investigating the disagreement between clinicians' ratings of patients in ICUs. IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics 17(4): 843-852, 2013

How Forcefully Should Clinicians Encourage Treatment When Disagreement Persists About Obesity Risk?. Ama Journal of Ethics 20(12): E1126-E1132, 2018

Disagreement between revascularization appropriateness scoring systems A prospective clinical comparison of RAND panel ratings, ACC/AHA guidelines, and the University of Maryland Revascularization Appropriateness Score. Circulation 90(4 Part 2): I43, 1994

Disagreement Between Clinicians and Score in Decision-Making Capacity of Critically Ill Patients. Critical Care Medicine 47(3): 337-344, 2019

Ethical challenge: when clinicians act as surrogates for unrepresented patients. American Journal of Critical Care 21(3): 202-207, 2012

How clinicians discuss critically ill patients' preferences and values with surrogates: an empirical analysis. Critical Care Medicine 43(4): 757-764, 2015

Sources of disagreement among clinicians' assessments of dangerousness in a psychiatric emergency room. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 15(3): 237-250, 1992

Disagreement between service-users and clinicians assessment of physical health during early psychosis. Early Intervention in Psychiatry 13(2): 314-317, 2019

Appropriateness of Outpatient Echocardiograms Ordered by Pediatric Cardiologists or Other Clinicians. Journal of Pediatrics 184: 137-142, 2017

The low prevalence of pulmonary embolism in patients with syncope: What should clinicians do?. American Journal of Emergency Medicine 36(10): 1917-1918, 2018

ICU clinicians' perceptions of appropriateness of care and the importance of nurse-physician collaboration. Archives of Internal Medicine 172(11): 889-890, 2012

Prevalence and appropriateness of procedures for altering oral dosage forms in a cohort of elderly institutionalized patients. Geriatrics and Gerontology International 16(3): 400-401, 2016

Appropriateness of care. Appropriateness of restorative treatment recommendations: a case for practice-based outcomes research. Journal of the American College of Dentists 59(2): 7, 1992

Assessment of Surrogates' Knowledge of Patients' Treatment Goals and Confidence in Their Ability to Make Surrogate Treatment Decisions. JAMA Internal Medicine 179(2): 267-268, 2019