EurekaMag
+ Most Popular
Cunninghamia lanceolata plantations in China
Mammalian lairs in paleo ecological studies and palynology
Studies on technological possibilities in utilization of anhydrous milk fat for production of recombined butter-like products
Should right-sided fibroelastomas be operated upon?
Large esophageal lipoma
Apoptosis in the mammalian thymus during normal histogenesis and under various in vitro and in vivo experimental conditions
Poissons characoides nouveaux ou non signales de l'Ilha do Bananal, Bresil
Desensitizing efficacy of Colgate Sensitive Maximum Strength and Fresh Mint Sensodyne dentifrices
Administration of fluid by subcutaneous infusion: revival of a forgotten method
Tundra mosquito control - an impossible dream?
Schizophrenia for primary care providers: how to contribute to the care of a vulnerable patient population
Geochemical pattern analysis; method of describing the Southeastern limestone regional aquifer system
Incidence of low birth weights in a hospital of Mexico City
Tabanidae
Graded management intensity of grassland systems for enhancing floristic diversity
Microbiology and biochemistry of cheese and fermented milk
The ember tetra: a new pygmy characid tetra from the Rio das Mortes, Brazil, Hyphessobrycon amandae sp. n. (Pisces, Characoidei)
Risk factors of contrast-induced nephropathy in patients after coronary artery intervention
Renovation of onsite domestic wastewater in a poorly drained soil
Observations of the propagation velocity and formation mechanism of burst fractures caused by gunshot
Systolic blood pressure in a population of infants in the first year of life: the Brompton study
Haematological studies in rats fed with metanil yellow
Studies on pasteurellosis. I. A new species of Pasteurella encountered in chronic fowl cholera
Dormancy breaking and germination of Acacia salicina Lindl. seeds
therapy of lupus nephritis. a two-year prospective study

Soils' dirty little secret: Depth-based comparisons can be inadequate for quantifying changes in soil organic carbon and other mineral soil properties


Soils' dirty little secret: Depth-based comparisons can be inadequate for quantifying changes in soil organic carbon and other mineral soil properties



Global Change Biology 26(7): 3759-3770



ISSN/ISBN: 1354-1013

PMID: 32307802

DOI: 10.1111/gcb.15124

Quantifying changes in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks and other soil properties is essential for understanding how soils will respond to land management practices and global change. Although they are widely used, comparisons of SOC stocks at fixed depth (FD) intervals are subject to errors when changes in bulk density or soil organic matter occur. The equivalent soil mass (ESM) method has been recommended in lieu of FD for assessing changes in SOC stocks in mineral soils, but ESM remains underutilized for SOC stocks and has rarely been used for other soil properties. In this paper, we draw attention to the limitations of the FD method and demonstrate the advantages of the ESM approach. We provide illustrations to show that the FD approach is susceptible to errors not only for quantifying SOC stocks but also for soil mass-based properties such as SOC mass percent, C:N mass ratio, and δ13 C. We describe the ESM approach and show how it mitigates the FD method limitations. Using bulk density change simulations applied to an empirical dataset from bioenergy cropping systems, we show that the ESM method provides consistently lower errors than FD when quantifying changes in SOC stocks and other soil properties. To simplify the use of ESM, we detail how the method can be integrated into sampling schemes, and we provide an example R computer script that can perform ESM calculations on large datasets. We encourage future studies, whether temporal or comparative, to utilize sampling methods that are amenable to the ESM approach. Overall, we agree with previous recommendations that ESM should be the standard method for evaluating SOC stock changes in mineral soils, but we further suggest that ESM may also be preferred for comparisons of other soil properties including mass percentages, elemental mass ratios, and stable isotope composition.

Please choose payment method:






(PDF emailed within 0-6 h: $19.90)

Accession: 070035348

Download citation: RISBibTeXText

Related references

The relationship of soil organic-carbon to soil color, soil texture, and other soil properties of selected North Dakota soils. Proceedings of the North Dakota Academy of Science 38(38): 41, 1984

Quantifying the relationship between soil organic carbon and soil physical properties using shrinkage modelling. European Journal of Soil Science 60(2): 265-275, 2009

Quantifying the relationship between soil organic carbon and soil physical properties using shrinkage modelling. European Journal of Soil Science 60.2, 2009

Soil properties controlling the adsorption of dissolved organic carbon to mineral soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal 73.6, 2009

Soil Properties Controlling the Adsorption of Dissolved Organic Carbon to Mineral Soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal 73(6): 1831-1842, 2009

Modelling soil organic carbon concentration of mineral soils in arable land using legacy soil data. European Journal of Soil Science 63(3): 351-359, 2012

Evaluating soil organic carbon stock changes induced by no-tillage based on fixed depth and equivalent soil mass approaches. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 300: 106982, 2020

Quantifying Tacit Knowledge about Soil Organic Carbon Stocks Using Soil Taxa and Official Soil Series Descriptions. Soil Science Society of America Journal 77(5): 1711-1723, 2013

Soil labile organic carbon fractions and soil organic carbon stocks as affected by long-term organic and mineral fertilization regimes in the North China Plain. Soil and Tillage Research 175: 281-290, 2018

Soil aggregation accounts for the mineral soil organic carbon and nitrogen accrual in broadleaved forests as compared to that of coniferous forests in Northeast China: Cross-sites and multiple species comparisons. Land Degradation and Development 32(1): 296-309, 2021

Understanding large-extent controls of soil organic carbon storage in relation to soil depth and soil-landscape systems. Global Biogeochemical Cycles 29(8): 1210-1229, 2015

The relationship of soil organic-c to soil color, soil texture, and other soil properties of selected North Dakota soils. Proceedings of the North Dakota Academy of Science 38: 41, 1984

Depth-dependent response of soil aggregates and soil organic carbon content to long-term elevated Co 2 in a temperate grassland soil. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 123: 145-154, 2018

Carbon isotopes of water-extractable organic carbon in a depth profile of forest soil imply a dynamic relationship with soil carbon. European Journal of Soil Science 63(4), 2012

Carbon isotopes of water-extractable organic carbon in a depth profile of forest soil imply a dynamic relationship with soil carbon. European Journal of Soil Science 63(4): 495-500, 2012